I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (2024)

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (1)

We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we love. Promise.

My holy grail beauty product? Gel eyeliner. Tbh, if I had to pick between gel and liquid eyeliner, I'd go with gel pretty much every single time. Why would I spend 15 minutes drawing and re-drawing a winged liner when I simply need a few seconds and my fave gel eyeliner? Not only are they oh-so-soft and silky against my eyelids, but they're also surprisingly versatile—smudge it out to make the smokiest smokey eye (good hack for when you mess up, FYI), or let it dry down to create the sharpest, ultra-precise line.

In other words, gel eyeliner is the makeup MVP that will help you achieve just about any beauty look. Because I want to share the wealth, I tapped celebrity makeup artist Renée Loiz to chime in on all things eyeliners. The formulas today are long-lasting, smudge-proof, and totally blendable, so there's honestly never been a better time to get on board Team Gel than right now.

Our top picks for the best gel eyeliners in 2024:

  • Best Overall Gel Liner

    Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

    Read more

  • Best Potted Gel Eyeliner

    Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner

    Read more

  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (7)

    Best Drugstore Gel Eyeliner

    Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil

    Read more

Keep reading for the full breakdown of the best gel eyeliners, according to my own testing and product reviewers, along with tips from our expert on what you should look for when selecting a gel eyeliner, the best way to apply gel eyeliner, and how to determine which eye look is right for you.

Best Overall Gel Liner

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (10)Super creamy, which means no tugging
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (11)You're going to need to sharpen it frequently due to the pencil design

Beauty lovers turn to this cult-favorite gel eyeliner for its incredibly creamy waterproof formula and 38 intensely pigmented colors (s/o to my favorite shade gold that looks incredible on all eye colors for a pop of color). Line or blend the gel-like tip across your lids, wait 15 seconds, then marvel at its clean finish that genuinely stays put.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: 38
  • Finish(es): Matte, satin, glitter, metallic, shimmer

Glowing Customer Review: "Love the selection, so many colors to pick from. I have to replace my favorites every now and then, but with a whole rainbow to play with, I always have inspiration. The formula is great on the waterline or anywhere on my skin."

Best Potted Gel Eyeliner

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (13)Cult-favorite that is vetted in the beauty community
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (14)You need a v precise hand, not for beginners

For those who feel like they’ve already mastered the art of applying eyeliner, this potted gel formula offers the most precise line when paired with a soft angled brush. The matte finish liner is intensely pigmented, so there will be no streaks or layering required—oh, and it's a cult-favorite due to how incredibly long-lasting the formula is.

  • Type: Pot
  • Shades: Black, deep black-brown, black-brown, dark red-brown
  • Finish(es): Matte

Glowing Customer Review: "Bobbi Brown gel eyeliner is the ONLY eyeliner that is truly smudge-proof, waterproof, and stays put all day regardless of the type of activity you are performing."

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Best Drugstore Gel Eyeliner

Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (15)

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (16)

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (17)Comes with a built-in blender
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (18)Tip may break off easily if you're not careful

New to eyeliner? Can’t nail the perfect cat eye? This drugstore gel eyeliner’s got you covered. The creamy, pigmented formula is easy to work with (it doesn’t skip or tug), and comes with a built-in blender to help create smokey or smudged looks—fast.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: 9
  • Finish(es): Matte

Glowing Customer Review: "I have been searching for a 'stay-put' eyeliner for years! Usually, I put them on in the morning, and at some point during the day, it all ends up under my eyes or running down my face. I put this on in the morning, and it stays right where I put it...AND looks like it did as soon as I put it on."

Best Gel Eyeliner for Oily Lids

Tom Ford Gel Eyeliner Pencil Cream

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (20)Liner comes in luxe, well made packaging that holds up over time
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (21)Most expensive option on this list

Tom Ford anything and I'm sold—s/o to the tried-and-true Shade and Illuminate. My newest find from the beauty collection, this gel eyeliner is no exception. The pigmented formula is creamy yet still firm enough for me to precisely line my eyes, and it glides across my lids with ease. The long-lasting liner is a game-changer for oily lids which has always been a struggle of mine. After a 15-hour day in humid weather, it didn't budge or fade, which is a game-changer in itself.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: Black, brown, nude
  • Finish(es): Matte

Glowing Customer Review: "I wear eyeliner daily and can honestly say this product is a game changer. I have incredibly oily skin, live in the humid south, and after 12 hours of wear in a healthcare setting this product is the only thing on my face that has not budged. No fading, smudging, nothing. The application is extremely smooth and pigmented—no pulling on my lids or patchiness whatsoever. The packaging is stunning and heavy. Overall, this is a high-performing, elevated product that isn’t just a 'luxury' name. It’s up there with the best."

Best Gel Liner Finish

Lancôme Drama Liqui-Pencil Longwear Eyeliner

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (23)Testers love it for their waterline
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (24)Some testers have trouble sharpening it

If a deeply-pigmented formula is what you're after, give this liner a try. The saturation is deep, and it's really cool to see how the formula goes from a solid to a liquid-like look as you apply it to your skin. It's basically like a step up from a liquid liner because, unlike liquid formulas where it's impossible to blend but incredible for high color payoff, you still get that blend-ability a gel provides.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: 6
  • Finish(es): Matte, glitter, metallic

Glowing Customer Review: "20+ years of searching for the perfect eyeliner for the waterline and I have finally found the one. I’d say it’s the best on the market, at least of the many high-end eyeliners I have tried over the years. Highly recommend the Lancome sharpener to go along with it."

Most Underrated Gel Eyeliner

Sephora Collection 12 Hour Contour Pencil Eyeliner

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (25)

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (26)Great affordable price for the quality
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (27)Testers complain that the waxy seal on the actual pencil makes it difficult to sharpen

This right here (and a ton of other beauty products) from Sephora's line is probably one of the most slept-on eyeliners in the market. With one stroke, it delivers a rich pigmented color that is easily blendable, but once set, is there to stay. Plus, it's got three different finishes, and over 20 shades, so you can craft whichever makeup look you're going for.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: 21
  • Finish(es): Matte, glitter, shimmer

Glowing Customer Review: "I have used different eyeliners in my life but this is the best one so far because it is long-lasting and very pigmented and won't smudge all day. Everyone asks me about this, and my friends also have purchased it and they liked it too."

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Most Customizable Gel Eyeliner

Rare Beauty Perfect Strokes Longwear & Waterproof Gel Eyeliner

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (29)Waterproof formula that doesn't budge
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (30)May need a few layers to build up to the pigment you want

If you’re after a ~sultry~ look, it’s time to enlist the help of Rare Beauty's incredibly blendable gel eyeliner, which can be layered on for an opaque cat eye or smudged into a hazy, smokey finish in just a few seconds.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: Black, brown, burgundy
  • Finish(es): Matte

Glowing Customer Review: "Initially ordered this eyeliner in brown and bought the black one immediately. This is everything I want in a gel eyeliner—smooth application with no tugging, and great pigment. Truly lasted over 12 hours and looked just as fresh."

Best Gel Eyeliner Pencil

ILIA Clean Line Gel Eyeliner

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (32)Super easy to glide on and apply to your liking
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (33)Formula can smudge; not ideal for fine-line looks

My introduction to eyeliner many, many moons ago was through pencil liner, so they still have a special place in my heart. But pencil meets gel? Now that's a whole 'nother level of efficiency. ILIA's Clean Line Gel Eyeliner is a favorite of mine because you get excellent precision with the pencil shape, PLUS the flexibility of the water-resistant gel formula.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: Brown, black
  • Finish(es): Matte

Glowing Customer Review: "I LOVE this eyeliner! This color brown really seems to make my eyes pop. It doesn’t require perfect application and is very workable. I have hooded eyes and this goes on very smoothly with minimal effort!"

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Most Precise Gel Eyeliner

Hourglass 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (34)

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (35)You can create super small and defined lines
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (36)Due to the small size, it breaks pretty easily with too much pressure

Think of this creamy gel eyeliner like a mechanical pencil—the über-thin, 1.5 mm tip makes incredibly neat and precise lines, so you can color in just your lash line, or layer it on for a thicker look.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: Black, brown, bronze
  • Finish(es): Matte

Glowing Customer Review: "The color is a rich, flattering color that makes the eyes pop. It doesn't turn ashy after it has been worn all day, doesn't smudge, and stays on until it is washed off."

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (38)Strong color payoff that lasts
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (39)May dry up on the eyelids too quickly before you can blend

Okay, very rarely do I ever wear anything other than black eyeliner—what can I say? I like what I like!—but on the rare occasions when I do, I reach for this classic. There are so many colors to choose from, ranging from bright teal (shown here) to fuchsia and lilac. The pigment is the real deal, and this formula can last up to 12 hours on the waterline (!!).

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: 15
  • Finish(es): Matte

Glowing Customer Review: "This is the only eyeliner that I have ever purchased (and I have tried A LOT of them) that the eyeliner didn't fade or run into the corner of my eyes. I love this product and am going back to buy it in more colors. The product goes on smooth."

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Most Blendable Gel Eyeliner

shiseido Kajal Ink Artist Shadow

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (40)

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (41)Blends like butter, so there won't be any pulling on your lids
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (42)Because they’re so blendable, it may be hard for you to be precise on your brows

I'm a beauty editor, I'm constantly testing out new formulas, so there are very few products I use on the day-to-day. This, however, makes the cut. It's quite possibly the creamiest, most blendable eye product I have ever applied to date, and it has multiple different uses including eyeliner, eyeshadow, and as a brow pencil. If I want a smokey eye, I apply it to my lid and blend it in using a fluffy brush, but if I want it more focused, I apply it to my lash line for a bit of definition.

  • Type: Chubby pencil
  • Shades: 7
  • Finish(es): Matte

Glowing Customer Review: "I got the brown color which they call tea. It’s a lovely shade of brown, glides on smoothly with no fuss, & is impressively waterproof. I apparently have very moist eyes such that if eye makeup doesn’t state that it’s waterproof, I don’t even bother. And most of those still don’t work out for me. This does. Perfect!"

Best Metallic Gel Eyeliner

SheGlam Chroma Zone Multichrome Gel Liner-Pixels

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (43)

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (44)Includes a smudge brush
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (45)Not widely available for purchase at mass retailers

A true metallic eyeliner is a hard feat to pull off—some lean shimmery, some aren't pigmented enough, and some just don't stay put. This one from the affordable brand, SheGlam checks all those boxes. With just one swipe on my lashline, I get this intensely deep metallic shade that glides on like butter and stays on all day long—just as vibrant as when I first applied it.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shade(s): Blue, blue-green, blue-yellow
  • Finish(es): Metallic

Glowing Customer Review: "Goes on like a dream. Lasts forever, the color is beautiful, and I get compliments EVERY time I wear it!!! I'll be getting all the colors."

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Best Gel Eyeliner Formula

Pat McGrath Labs Permagel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (47)Deeply pigmented color that works great for a smokey eye
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (48)Don't have a lot of time to work with it before it dries

The majority of gel eyeliners are twist-ups (meaning, nope, you can't sharpen 'em)—but this pencil-gel hybrid isn't most eyeliners. Translation: You get the creamy, silky texture of waterproof gel with all the ease of a pencil. Just know that when this baby sets, it sets, so if you're going for a smokey-eye look, make sure you smudge it out ASAP.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: 5
  • Finish(es): Matte, shimmer

Glowing Customer Review: "The formula is creamy, easily blendable, and long wearing. I can wear it on my upper and/or bottom lash line with no issues; it has great color payoff and doesn’t tug on the skin when applied."

Best Kohl Gel Eyeliner

ONE/SIZE Point Made 24-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (49)

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (50)The best for a smokey eye
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (51)You need to sharpen it once in a while to create a thinner and clean line during application

If you love the glide of gel eyeliner but want the smudgy texture of kohl, go for this pencil from MUA Patrick Starrr. It's waterproof, super pigmented (like, a-little-goes-a-long-way pigmented), vegan, and cruelty-free. You can't really go wrong with this one.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: Black, brown
  • Finish(es): Matte

Glowing Customer Review: "This is a really good eyeliner! I’ve been looking for an eyeliner that wouldn’t smear on my bottom lash line, and this sucker holds up really well! I wore it to work and it was extremely hot and I was sweating, and it stayed perfectly fine!"

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Most Moisturizing Gel Eyeliner

Wander Beauty Side Liner Automatic Gel Eyeliner

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (52)

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (53)No tugging or pulling thanks to the rich blend of emollients
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (54)Not great for oily skin

This gel eyeliner is formulated with a cocktail of skin-softening ingredients (think: olive oil, jojoba oil, and vitamin E) that work to keep your liner smooth and non-flaky all day long. But don’t worry—even though it’s super creamy, it also has legit staying powers thanks to its waterproof eyeliner formula.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: Black, tan, purple
  • Finish(es): Satin

Glowing Customer Review: "I usually hate eyeliner because it's so hard to put on and get a perfect wing every time, but this liner makes it super easy to glide on and get the wing you want. I will buy this again and again."

Best Gel Eyeliner Shade Range

Haus Labs Optic Intensity Eco Gel Eyeliner Pencil

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (56)A ton of variety in terms of shades and glitter
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (57)Due to its budge-proof formula, it may be difficult to remove

Raise your hand if you love to throw a little color on your eye looks (🙋🙋🙋)!!! Lady Gaga's beauty line, Haus Laboratories, has one of the most extensive shade lines I've seen. Choose from a variety of 18 colors and finishes—including shimmer, matte, and metallic—to brighten up your next eye look.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: 18
  • Finish(es): Shimmer, matte, metallic

Glowing Customer Review: "This eyeliner is great. It goes on like a charm, works on the waterline, and stays on all day. I have purchased other brands that just smear after several hours of wear. The colors in this line are fantastic and fun! Will be adding more to my makeup stash."

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Best Gel Eyeliner Duo

Tarte Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner

Pros
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (59)Applies like a gel, finishes like a liquid
Cons
  • I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (60)Reviews say the felt end is a bit too blunt

If you stan liquid liner (props to you, you're prob talented AF) and want to experiment with the likes of gel, the Tarte Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner is the product for you. Not only do you get both gel and liquid eyeliner, but the duo product allows you to create the coolest eye looks. The best part? It's waterproof and long-wearing.

  • Type: Pencil
  • Shades: Black, brown
  • Finish(es): Matte

Glowing Customer Review: "I really like this eyeliner because of how pigmented it is. I personally like my eyeliner to be done in one stroke and this is perfect for it. Plus it WON'T wash away with water, and so that is another great bonus."

Which gel eyeliner is best?

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (61)

The best gel eyeliner all depends on your own preference, but makeup artist Renée Loiz says it’s all about finding the right balance. With so many gel formulas to choose from, be patient as you experiment. You may be a fan of creamier options, or you may need something with a drier finish. Your ideal gel eyeliner could be a formula that's a bit of both. "While I like a creamy texture to a gel liner, I also like it to have a bit of a dry texture, too," Loiz says. "This ensures the liner won’t likely move or smudge."

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Why does my gel eyeliner always smudge?

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (62)

If not properly primed or set, gel eyeliners can smudge. According to Loiz, the secret to smudge-free gel eyeliner is adding a few key products. "If you have oilier eyelids, use a primer on the lids first to remove the oil," she says. Then, apply gel liner. You can also set with either makeup spray or translucent setting powder."

What is the best brush for a gel eyeliner?

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (63)

Embrace the angle

Once you've found a formula you love (ahhh, what a feeling!), it's time to snag a brush that'll help you achieve that super-precise look. "I like to use both a thin, angled brush to get close to the lash liner or a fine liner brush to get a more precise line," Loiz says.

The best way to apply gel eyeliner

I don't know about you, but I've been applying eyeliner in the same way for a really long time. Turns out, switching up where you start the line (genius, no?) can totally change your look. For instance, when applying gel eyeliner, Loiz starts from the middle of the eye and works her way outwards. "Then I apply the liner from the inner corner and connect the line to where I initially started in the middle," she says. "Lastly, I angle the line outwards if I’m adding a cat liner or to elongate the liner."

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (64)

Siena Gagliano

Associate Editor

Siena Gagliano is the associate editor at Cosmopolitan, where she primarily covers beauty, fashion, travel, and lifestyle. Wanna know how to get the best brows of your life? Gotchu. What about how to find the best fashion deals of the season, the softest sheets on the market, or exactly how to use retinol without irritating your skin? Check, check, and check. Before joining Cosmopolitan, Siena was a writer at Bustle and several other media outlets. As her 2024 goal, she has vowed to find the best (extra) dirty martini NYC has to offer—and yes, that means ~attempting~ to try every cute cocktail spot in the city (hit her up with some recs, pls). Follow Siena on Instagram for a behind-the-scenes look at that magazine life.

I Tested a Ton of Gel Eyeliners, and These Are the Smudge-Proof Winners (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Greg O'Connell

Last Updated:

Views: 6480

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (42 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Greg O'Connell

Birthday: 1992-01-10

Address: Suite 517 2436 Jefferey Pass, Shanitaside, UT 27519

Phone: +2614651609714

Job: Education Developer

Hobby: Cooking, Gambling, Pottery, Shooting, Baseball, Singing, Snowboarding

Introduction: My name is Greg O'Connell, I am a delightful, colorful, talented, kind, lively, modern, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.